The Pros and Cons of Different Roofing Materials: Which Is Right for You?

Request a FREE Estimate


Choosing the suitable roofing material is crucial to maintaining your home’s integrity and aesthetics. There are various roofing materials to choose from, each with its advantages and disadvantages. This guide will provide you with a comprehensive understanding of different roofing materials’ pros and cons and assist you in making an informed decision for your roofing project.

roofer in white helmet

1. Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most commonly used roofing material in the United States, known for their affordability and versatility. They come in two main types: three-tab and architectural shingles.


  • Affordability: They are budget-friendly and readily available, making them a popular choice for homeowners.
  • Ease of Installation: Roofers find them easy to install, reducing labor costs.
  • Variety: They have various styles and colors, allowing you to customize your roof’s appearance.
  • Climate Adaptability: They work well in most climates.


  • Limited Lifespan: Asphalt shingles typically last 20-30 years, making them less durable than other materials.
  • Susceptible to Damage: They can be damaged by high winds and hail.
  • Environmental Impact: Asphalt shingles are not the most eco-friendly option, as they are petroleum-based and not easily recyclable.

2. Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has gained popularity for its exceptional longevity and durability, with materials like steel, aluminum, and copper being common choices.


  • Longevity: Outlasting many other materials, metal roofs have a lifespan of more than 50 years.
  • Durability: They are highly weather-resistant, including rain, snow, and hail.
  • Energy Efficiency: Metal roofs reflect sunlight and heat, reducing cooling costs.
  • Low Maintenance: They require minimal upkeep.


  • Higher Initial Cost: Metal roofing materials can be more expensive than asphalt shingles.
  • Noise: They can cause noise during heavy rain or hail storms without proper insulation.
  • Limited Aesthetic Options: Metal roofs have fewer color choices than other materials.

3. Wood Shingles and Shakes

Wood shingles and shakes offer a natural, rustic appearance and are often used for their aesthetic appeal.


  • Aesthetic Appeal: Wood shingles give your home a charming, natural look.
  • Insulation Properties: They offer good insulation.
  • Long Lifespan: Proper maintenance of wood roofing can last 30-40 years.


  • Prone to Damage: Wood is susceptible to mold, rot, and insect infestations.
  • High Maintenance: Regular maintenance, including staining and sealing, is required.
  • Fire Restrictions: Wood roofing may not be suitable for fire-prone areas due to their combustibility.

4. Slate Roofing

Slate roofing is renowned for its exquisite appearance and unmatched longevity, often exceeding a century in lifespan.


  • Elegant Appearance: Slate roofs provide a timeless and elegant aesthetic.
  • Incredible Durability: They can last 100+ years with proper care.
  • Low Maintenance: Slate requires minimal maintenance to stay in top condition.


  • Weight: Slate is hefty and may necessitate additional roof support.
  • High Installation Cost: The initial cost of slate roofing may be significant.
  • Skilled Labor Requirement: Finding qualified installers for slate can be challenging due to its specialized nature.

5. Clay and Concrete Tiles

Clay and concrete tiles, popular in Mediterranean-style homes, boast beautiful and distinctive aesthetics.


  • Aesthetic Appeal: Clay and concrete tiles provide a unique and appealing appearance.
  • Longevity: They have a lifespan of 50+ years.
  • Fire Resistance: They are fire-resistant, adding to your home’s safety.
  • Low Maintenance: These tiles require minimal upkeep.


  • Weight: They are heavy and often require structural modifications to support the load.
  • Fragility: Tiles can break if walked on, requiring cautious maintenance.

Enhance Your Home with Krumm Exteriors

Selecting the suitable roofing material involves considering your budget, climate, aesthetic preferences, and maintenance capabilities. Each roofing material has its unique pros and cons, and by evaluating these factors carefully, you can make an informed choice that will enhance your home’s functionality and appearance. When making your final decision, it’s advisable to consult with a professional roofer who can provide valuable insights and recommendations based on your specific needs.

If you’re looking for professional advice on choosing the best roofing material for your house, rely on Krumm Exteriors. This reliable contractor provides gutters, windows, siding, and roofing services. Krumm Exteriors has been serving the residents of Wisconsin and Minnesota with a commitment to excellence since 1997, emphasizing long-term property value.

Call us today at 715-312-2766 and upgrade your property with a lasting roofing solution. Your dream home is just a consultation away.