Metal vs Asphalt Roof: Which Material Is Best For My Home?

Request a FREE Estimate


Roofs are essential to your home as they protect it from the elements and add to its curb appeal. When choosing the right roofing material, homeowners often find themselves torn between two popular options: metal vs asphalt roof materials. Though both materials work exceptionally well at protecting homes, it is vital to understand the pros and cons of each and what each material offers.

Pros and Cons

With all of the advantages of the years regarding your metal vs asphalt roof in Wisconsin, it can be difficult to determine which is right for you. For this reason, it is important to consider the characteristics of each. Each roofing material has some positive and negative qualities.

Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles

When it comes to asphalt shingles, one of the main advantages is their affordability. They are a cost-effective roofing option, which is ideal for homeowners looking to stick to a budget. Additionally, asphalt shingles come in various colors and styles, making it much easier to find the color that best matches your home’s aesthetic.

On the downside, asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan than metal roofing. They typically last around 15-30 years, so they may need to be replaced sooner than other materials. Additionally, when comparing metal vs asphalt roof, asphalt shingles are more prone to damage from severe weather conditions like strong winds or hail. However, with proper installation and maintenance, asphalt shingles can still provide adequate protection for your home at a reasonable price.

Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing

Alternatively, metal roofing offers homes a sleek and modern aesthetic, which can add a contemporary touch to any property. Metal roofs are far more durable than many other materials. This material has the ability to withstand harsh weather conditions such as heavy snow, high winds, and hail. When comparing metal vs asphalt roof materials, the durability of metal roofs ensures you will have to deal with fewer repairs and replacements over time.

In addition, metal roofing is generally more economically friendly than shingles. These roofs often utilize recyclable materials. Additionally, the reflective properties of metal can contribute to energy efficiency in homes, further reducing their environmental impact.

One drawback of metal roofing is the initial cost, which can be higher than traditional asphalt shingles. However, this upfront investment often pays off in the long run due to the extended lifespan of metal roofs. Additionally, some homeowners may find rain hitting a metal roof noisier than other roofing materials.

However, it is essential to note that metal roofs are highly energy-efficient and environmentally friendly. They reflect solar radiant heat, reducing cooling costs during hot summer months. Metal roofing is also recyclable at the end of its life cycle, making it a sustainable choice for eco-conscious homeowners looking to reduce their carbon footprint.

Metal vs Asphalt Roof: Important Factors to Consider

Consider a few things when choosing between a metal vs asphalt roof in Minnesota.

The Weather 

Although we do not see many extreme weather conditions in the Wisconsin and Minneapolis areas, it is crucial to consider the weather when selecting. Metal roofing is particularly suitable for areas with extreme weather conditions, while asphalt shingles may be sufficient in milder climates.

Your Budget

The amount of money you have to invest in your roofing project upfront is critical in determining which material is best for your home. Asphalt shingles may be a more cost-effective option upfront, while metal roofing offers potential savings over the life of the roof.

Aesthetic Preferences

The metal vs asphalt roof materials each provide a different aesthetic to your home. It is vital to evaluate the architectural style of your home and your personal design preferences. Asphalt shingles offer a traditional look with many options, while metal roofing provides a modern and sleek appearance.

Finally, you should consider whether you plan to remain in your home indefinitely. A shingle roof may be better if you want to move within a few years. However, if you plan to stay in your home for a long time, metal roofing may be more suitable. 

The Installation Process

When comparing metal vs asphalt roof materials, it is vital to consider the installation and maintenance requirements. Generally, asphalt shingles are easier and quicker to install than metal roofing, which can be more complex due to its rigid nature.

Installation costs can vary depending on the material chosen, so it’s important to factor this into your decision-making process. Additionally, consider the maintenance needs of each type – asphalt shingles may require periodic repairs or replacements over time. In contrast, metal roofs are known for their durability and longevity, with minimal maintenance required.

Why You Should Hire a Professional

When installing a new roof, hiring a professional contractor is crucial. Our experts have the skills and experience to ensure the job is done correctly. They know local building codes and regulations, which helps prevent any issues.

Our professional contractors also have access to high-quality materials and tools that may not be readily available to homeowners. This ensures that your roof will be durable and long-lasting. Additionally, they can provide valuable advice on choosing the most appropriate material for your specific home needs.

Hiring our professionals to handle your installation job can help you save time and avoid making costly mistakes trying to handle the project independently. Our team will ensure your roof is installed correctly and on schedule, so you do not have to worry. 

Call Our Experts Today

Regardless of your choice of metal vs asphalt roof materials, you can rest assured that our team at Krumm Exteriors uses only high-quality materials. We are committed to the quality and services we provide, ensuring you will be satisfied with your purchase.

Over the past 20 years, Krumm Exteriors has proudly served Western Wisconsin and Minnesota as a reliable, family-owned and operated roofing and siding company. Our dedication to providing high-quality services with professionalism has been our top priority since day one. With fully licensed professionals in Wisconsin and Minnesota, we guarantee that your exterior remodeling goals will be achieved with excellence. Call our team now in our Wisconsin office by calling (715) 402-4070 or our Minnesota office by calling (651) 360-2663 to schedule an appointment.